Project management practice
Project budget variance example: separate spend from forecast
Calculate forecast cost and budget variance, explain the assumptions, and avoid mistaking low spend for healthy delivery.
Low spend can still hide an overrun
Actual cost tells you what has been spent. It does not tell you whether the remaining work can be delivered within the budget. Start with actual cost to date plus an updated estimate to complete, using the same currency and cost basis.
This is a simple forecast method for practice. It is not earned value analysis, financial advice or a confidence interval. Check committed but unbilled costs, tax treatment, contingency and duplicated estimates before using a real forecast.
Worked example: a delayed installation
| Measure | Illustrative amount | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Approved budget | 20,000 units | Authorised baseline. |
| Actual cost to date | 12,000 units | Recorded cost at the reporting date. |
| Estimate to complete | 10,000 units | Remaining work and expected costs, excluding amounts already counted. |
| Forecast at completion | 22,000 units | 12,000 + 10,000. |
| Forecast variance | +2,000 units / +10% | Forecast minus budget; positive means over budget in this guide. |
Explain what changed in the estimate
The project has spent only 60% of its budget, but the forecast is 10% over. That could reflect additional work, a rate increase, rework or an incomplete original estimate. Break the movement into causes instead of treating the arithmetic as the explanation.
Ask whether purchase commitments are included in actual cost, the remaining estimate, or neither. Counting a supplier invoice in both actuals and remaining work creates an artificial overrun. Omitting an agreed but unbilled commitment hides one.
Copyable forecast bridge
Reporting date / currency / cost basis: Approved budget and version: Actual cost to date: Remaining estimate / owner / estimate date: Commitments not otherwise counted: Forecast total / variance / sign convention: Change since last forecast and causes: Contingency remaining and authority: Decision needed / options / deadline:
Use the number to frame a decision
If the overrun is outside delegated tolerance, state the options and approval needed. Reducing scope, changing sequencing or requesting budget are different choices with different consequences. Do not promise savings until the affected owner validates them.
The delivery-check tool calculates this simple comparison and labels the sign convention. It cannot decide whether a cost is allowable, whether the estimate is complete or whether a change should be approved.
Method background
These sources provide general background. The worked examples and worksheets are original Response Shift teaching material; the organisations do not endorse this product.
